Crew member trapped his left index finger in watertight door

What happened

A fitter’s left index finger was pinched between the moving door edge and door frame causing small abrasions to the index finger. The incident occurred during testing of the watertight door following a visual alarm on the bridge which had indicated that a watertight door near one of the engine rooms was open. The Engine control room was contacted and requested to investigate the door status. A fitter was sent to check the door. Upon arrival he noted that the door was closed; however, the audible alarm was going off, indicating that the door was open. He began testing the door, which involved cycling it from closed to open. As he did so, his left hand was positioned flat on the moving door whilst his right hand was used to operate the hydraulic door lever. His focus was on the locating pin and sensor where he believed the fault to be, and he didn’t realise his hand had moved into the line of fire. As he closed the door he got his finger caught between the moving door edge and door frame resulting in a minor injury.

Although the actual consequence of this case resulted in a minor injury the potential consequences of incorrect conduct with watertight doors could have resulted in a serious injury.

What went wrong

• The fitter’s extreme focus on fault finding caused him to miss the important fact that his hand was in the line of fire;
• There were other distractions such as high noise levels from the machinery space, the door alarm, and flashing light which could have contributed to his lapse of concentration;
• Our member notes a non-contributing factor was the routine practice of leaving watertight doors in the open position whilst at sea. This could result in a detention by Port State Control or more importantly the risk to the integrity of the vessel when at sea.

Learning

• Controlling or modifying human behaviour is a difficult managerial challenge, which requires a commitment to safety, and the effective use of education, training, monitoring and enforcement.

Members may wish to refer to:

• LTI: person crushed in watertight door
• Line of fire: pinched finger between door and frame
• Lost time injury (LTI): Finger injury – watertight sliding door